Dear Grue,
No, you are not a hippie. However, you are probably a dumb consumer. Most of those "eco-friendly" and "pure organic" products taste worst and spoil faster than conventionally grown items, they use more land and are actually less safe. There's a reason why food science has taken great leaps over the years and the recent move towards the no science approach amazes me.
You're not a hippie, but you are probably paying 3-4 times as much for items which are either no better than or worse than what you would normally get anywhere else.