Dieb said:
Hey, Barack Obama has picked up another endorsement: Halfrican American actress Halle Berry. "As a Halfrican American, I am honored to have Ms. Berry's support, as well as the support of other Halfrican Americans.
Now, I have a problem with that statement.
Which, lets be clear, you are allowed to. I see it as satire/parody similar to South Park. Offensive? Yes? Funny? Not to you (incidentally, not to me either but then again I don't laugh at every single joke on South Park so I guess two individuals can't be the arbiter's of what is or isn't actually funny can we?) but unlike you I don't find racism in it.
Dieb said:
Just as I have a problem with the phrase "Barack the Magic Negro". It's ugly and dehumanizing.
Mr. Limbaugh would agree with you on that. That was the entire reason he used it in his parody. A liberal calling the black candidate "The Magic Negro". Makes for a hell of a parody don't it? As to why he used Sharpton, well, we will get to that below
Dieb said:
Now, if it had been funny, that'd be another thing. Like SNL and Chappelle, you know that they are joking, at least in part because they are actually funny.
You are dealing entirely with subjective things here and cannot seriously expect me to agree that you are the one who says what is joking or isn't. If you don't "know" when Rush is using parody or making points through humor then again, we have to agree to disagree. That's really all we can do.
Dieb said:
And Gwen Ifill is a silly comparison, she was having a serious discussion about the issues involved, which I think we can all agree Limbaugh was not going for.
Ah, now here is the meat of the thing where you totally missed my boat. The reason I brought Gwen Ifill up is because her issue was one that was discussed prominantly in the media during the election, by everyone from Sharpton to Jackson to Obama (hell, he even LIED about his ties to the movement in Selma, so obviously he understood the need to connect with the previous generation of Black leaders) to the MSM. So Rush creates a parody that focuses on this issue. Was he going for a "serious" discussion of the issue? Only so far as any of the other entertainers do, but that's not the point. The point is it was exactly Ms. Ifill's issue that Rush was commenting on. To not see that misses the ENTIRE point of the bit, after all that was
THE reason he used Sharpton. To tie the issues together.
Dieb said:
Now, obviously, funny is an arbitrary standard. People can certainly differ on these kinds of matters. I'm just saying, FOR ME, it crossed the line.
Nice to see you agree with me here but since your post is riddled with things like:
"Now, if it had been funny"
"you know that they are joking"
"they are actually funny."
"...Limbaugh was not going for"
how do I know which version of your post to go with? The one where you say "It isn't funny and thats THAT" or the one where you say "I don't personally find it funny". Those are quite different things. One mindset leaves no room for discussion and one does.
Dieb said:
I'm not advocating any action based on this. Just that it's not the sort of thing that I would want to do, nor would people that I respect.
That's fair. A lot of people don't respect the South Park guys and with damn good reason. But I'm not going to scream RACISM or HOMOPHOBIA whenever they satirize or make fun of those things. I think I will close today with some words from Clint Eastwood, ''
I don't want to be politically correct. We're all spending too much time and energy trying to be politically correct about everything."
Thanks for the good discussion Dieb.
(and sorry if I don't make sense, I'm on my first cup of coffee this morning!)