[Question] Personal Jesus
- Thread starter HCGLNS
- Start date
- Status
I'm gonna go with Marylon Manson. Not saying the original isn't great which it is, but Marylon Manson's version is the one I grew up on plus I feel the changes he made to the tune were freaking awesome.
The original is great, but Cash's guitar sold me on that version. Those two are neck and neck, but that's what put me over the top.
Manson's comes in a distant 4th.
Manson's comes in a distant 4th.
...okay yeah that is probably better. Either way, both versions sound really awesome with noise cancelling head-phones.
Ever.
I was just coming here to post this. I still love all of Manson's older stuff but Gravity Kills version is far better and as you add, it really sounds like he ripped them off.
Finally took some time to listen to them all, and based on the audio (didn't watch the videos), I have to go with the original as the best version, and Gravity Kills as the best cover. Manson muddied it too much, and Cash's version sounds more like a jam session than something he is pouring his heart and soul into (like he did with "Hurt").
--Patrick
--Patrick
I'm not a music guy, so I've never even heard of this song, whatever the version. So, in that case, I'll just go with:
No love for Danzig?
http://music.yahoo.com/blogs/stop-t...nson-gives-audience-real-shock-173942617.html
as good place as any for this... He passed out in the middle of a show.
as good place as any for this... He passed out in the middle of a show.
Props to him for continuing the tour, he's a hard working entertainer. A lot of stars would wimp out and cancel shows.
I actually loved his cover of Tainted Love.
I tend to like Manson's covers. Tainted Love, Nightmare Before Christmas, Golden Years etc.
I gotta go with Cash, which seems to be bucking the popular opinion 'round these parts.
Huh?
I meant in this thread. I don't believe anyone said that everything David Bowie does is great, except for you, poe, waaaaay back in the thread.
If he's responding to your post form that far back, he really should have quoted it, otherwise he just comes of as someone blurting random arguments.
I'll find it hilarious if he's referring to I'm Afraid of Americans as being a cover, seeing as it's an original Bowie song.
If he's responding to your post form that far back, he really should have quoted it, otherwise he just comes of as someone blurting random arguments.
I'll find it hilarious if he's referring to I'm Afraid of Americans as being a cover, seeing as it's an original Bowie song.
I was replying to this, but apparently didn't reply to it.
Nothing anyone does is 100% perfect, but artists like Bowie are very much more hit than miss.
True enough, but really, if you told someone with any sense that Mick Jagger and David Bowie were doing a cover to a song their response should be a unanimous shout of joy.
1:04, Mick Jagger nightmare face.
Don't open this
Stop now
Really it's for your own good....
Fine, you were warned.
- Status